Case Studies

Real public tenders analyzed with NOXAR Methodology v1.1. Three sectors, three outcomes.

26-54686

CSAPA fit-out + day hospital

Sector: Hospital / Healthcare·Buyer: CHU Grenoble Alpes

55

THS / 100

Recommendation: HIGH CAUTION (THS-only)Confidence: LOW

Key Findings

51-file DCE with 7 lots — deep and realistic hospital package
Active CHU site: no lift, no skip, severe logistics constraints
Initial veto triggers were application errors, not methodology gaps

Read full analysis →

26-56418

Impact cannon zone rehabilitation — DGA-TA BALMA

Sector: Military public building·Buyer: Ministry of Armed Forces — SID-SE

71

THS / 100

Recommendation: GO WITH CONDITIONSConfidence: MEDIUM

Key Findings

48-file DCE: RC, CCAP, 3 CCTPs, DPGF, PGC, RICT, 15 plans
14-month schedule aligned with planning prévisionnel (M1–M14)
Military access, badge controls, and compliance overhead are primary bid risks

Read full analysis →

26-53573

RCEA RN79 — Site installation

Sector: VRD / Highway infrastructure·Buyer: DREAL Bourgogne-Franche-Comté

68

THS / 100

Recommendation: NO GO (HV-04)Confidence: LOW

Key Findings

CCAP, CCTP, DQE/BPUF present — strong technical package
RC listed in sommaire but absent from downloadable DCE
64-month installation + maintenance contract on active RCEA corridor

Read full analysis →